Advanced Search

DPA Puts Synthetics Detectors to the Test

Mar 5, 2019 10:45 AM   By Rapaport News
Comment Comment Email Email Print Print Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter Share Share

RAPAPORT... A synthetics detector costing less than $7,000 is one of only two machines that conclusively identified 100% of lab-grown diamonds in a recent industry-wide study.

Yehuda’s Sherlock Holmes, priced at $6,495, correctly spotted all synthetic diamonds in a “deliberately challenging” sample, according to a report the Diamond Producers Association (DPA) and Signet Jewelers released Tuesday.

De Beers’ DiamondView, which costs $35,000, also scored full marks. DiamondView didn’t mislabel any synthetics as natural, while Sherlock Holmes was wrong for 2.5% of mined stones.

Two other De Beers products, SYNTHdetect ($17,000) and DiamondSure ($18,200), accurately referred all lab-growns for further testing, as did the Gemological Institute of America’s (GIA) iD100 ($4,995), HRD Antwerp’s M-Screen+ ($63,000), and Presidium’s Synthetic Diamond Screener II ($599). Those machines are designed to refer synthetics rather than detect them conclusively, according to the study, known as the Assure Program.

The DPA and Signet tested the ability of 18 scanners from 11 manufacturers to identify natural diamonds, synthetics and simulants from a mixed batch, the two organizations said. They assessed the machines’ performances against a standard developed by UL, a third-party testing agency, as well as a technical committee comprising scientists and academics from gemological institutions, including the GIA and De Beers’ International Institute of Diamond Grading & Research. Testing took place at UL’s laboratories in Canton, Massachusetts.

The wide-ranging research looked at how well each contraption detected or referred man-made stones, including the rate at which they gave false positives. The DPA has published the full results in a directory on its website.

The directory also lists key characteristics of the machines, such as whether they work automatically or manually or require an expert operator, as well as the speed at which they process stones, which varies significantly.

For instance, DiamondView and Sherlock Holmes require expert operators, while a novice can use Synthetic Diamond Screener II. Not all the machines in the test work on mounted jewelry, and one of them, Taidiam Technology’s DiamondDect 5, only looks for High Pressure-High Temperature (HPHT) goods.

“Through the Assure Program, we will support the diamond trade, from independent jewelry retailers to large diamond manufacturers, to make informed decisions on how to ensure that undisclosed laboratory-grown diamonds do not enter their natural-diamond supply chain,” said DPA CEO Jean-Marc Lieberherr.

The Assure program will update its directory as manufacturers submit new instruments, it said.

Clarification, March 6, 2019: This article was updated to clarify the methods and results of the test.

Correction, March 11, 2019: The Assure Program’s initial report on Presidium’s Synthetic Diamond Screener II incorrectly stated that it had scored 100% for “synthetic-diamond accuracy,” which refers to its ability to identify lab-grown stones conclusively. The report also incorrectly gave the machine a “synthetic-diamond false-positive” score of 15.5%, implying that it wrongly classified that percentage of all natural diamonds as synthetic. The Assure Program has since updated its report to reflect that the machine only refers stones for further testing, rather than categorically identifying them. As such, the device no longer has a score for either of those categories, and instead has a “synthetic-diamond referral rate” of 100%, which means it correctly referred all synthetics for further testing. We have updated this article with those factual changes. The update also means that only two machines in the Assure test conclusively identified 100% of lab-grown diamonds, and not three as this story previously said.

Image: A selection of detection machines that underwent testing. (Diamond Producers Association)
Comment Comment Email Email Print Print Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter Share Share
Tags: Assure Program, Canton, De Beers, detection, Diamond Producers Association, DiamondView, Dpa, Gemological Institute of America, GIA, HRD Antwerp, iD100, International Institute of Diamond Grading & Research, Jean-Marc Lieberherr, Massachusetts, M-Screen+, Rapaport News, Sherlock Holmes, Signet, Signet Jewelers, SYNTHdetect, Synthetic Diamond Screener II, Synthetic diamonds, Synthetics, synthetics detection, technology, UL, Yehuda
Similar Articles
Comments: (0)  Add comment Add Comment
Arrange Comments Last to First