Rapaport Magazine
Legacy

At What Price Love?

Engagement rings of the rich, famous and fabulous have an added value all their own.

By Phyllis Schiller


Suzanne Belperron hammered gold and cushion-shaped diamond engagement ring, circa 1923. Photo courtesy Sotheby’s.

From the much-married Elizabeth Taylor to King Edward VIII, who gave up his throne to marry the woman he loved, Wallis Simpson, the love affairs of the rich, royal or merely famous have fascinated the public for decades. And by extension, their choices in engagement rings, the tangible expression of a couple’s pursuit of a romantic happily-ever-after, are every bit as compelling.

PUTTING A RING ON IT

While they say you can’t put a price on love, making sense — and dollars and cents — of the value of the engagement rings of those in the spotlight is an entirely different matter. “A prestigious provenance certainly adds to the value of the rings,” says Patrick van der Vorst, a former director at Sotheby’s London for over 12 years and founder of the online appraisal service, ValueMyStuff.com.

   Observing the sales of celebrity rings over the past decade has allowed van der Vorst to gauge how an “interesting provenance” affects the price achieved at auction. Choosing a selection of engagement rings belonging to twentieth-century headliners, from Hollywood stars to iconic designers, he has compiled a list of “notable” engagement rings and their celebrity pedigrees. While some feature diamonds, which, says van der Vorst, “have always been popular and will certainly remain the preferred stones for engagement rings,” others feature alternative stones and settings. The common denominator is that the original owners all celebratedtheir engagements with distinctive rings.

LEADING LADIES

Audrey Meadows, who played Alice Kramden in the classic 1950s American television comedy, “The Honeymooners,” married Robert Six, aviation pioneer and president of Continental Airlines, in 1961. Her engagement ring starred a 3.75-carat pear-shaped diamond flanked by two tapered baguette diamonds in a platinum setting. It sold at Sotheby’s New York on December 4, 2007, for $34,600*, more than double the presale estimate of $12,000 to $15,000.
   Screen icon Deborah Kerr (1921-2007) opted for a three-stone ring with three brilliant-cut diamonds in a yellow tint for her first marriage to Squadron Leader Anthony Bartley in November 1945. The diamonds, weighing 2.32, 2.98 and 2.17 carats respectively, were each mounted within a four-claw setting. Bonham’s London sold the engagement ring for $53,000 in December 2008.
   Hollywood actress Ila Rhodes was supposedly once engaged to then-actor and future U.S. President Ronald Reagan. She ultimately moved to Brazil, where she married a Brazilian industrialist who gave her a diamond and platinum ring created and signed by famed French jewelry designer Pierre Sterlé, circa 1950. Taking top billing was a rectangular cut diamond, weighing 7.29 carats, centered within a crossover bombé mounting of pavé-set round brilliant and baguette-cut diamonds weighing approximately 3.30 carats total. Bonham’s sold her engagement ring in New York in 2011 for $122,500.

ARTFUL CREATIONS

Elma Rumsey was the daughter of Moses Rumsey, a wealthy industrialist from St. Louis. Her 19.01-carat, cushion-cut, F color, SI1 diamond was given to her by her fiancé, Pierre Cartier, on their engagement. He was one of the three legendary Cartier brothers who created the well-known jewelry house. The center diamond is flanked by baguette-cut diamonds and mounted in platinum. Estimated at $500,000 to $600,000, it sold at Christie’s New York in April 2001 for $545,000.
   When sculptor Alexander Calder (1898-1976) put an engagement ring on his wife Louisa’s finger, it was of his own design and making. Calder created the ring by heating a single piece of gold wire, hammering it flat and then shaping it into a triple-band ring with a spiral plaque on top.
   Influential French jewelry designer Suzanne Belperron came to prominence in the 1920s and ’30s as a designer for René Boivin. She went on to establish her own shop in the Rue de Châteaudun, where her customers included the Duchess of Windsor, according to the November 15, 1937, issue of American Vogue. For Belperron’s own engagement ring, circa 1923, featuring an old mine diamond, she created a singular hammered gold crossover design. The so-called “Yin and Yang” ring was auctioned, along with a selection of other jewels from her personal collection, on May 14, 2012, at Sotheby’s Geneva. Estimated at $12,300 to $19,000, the ring sold for $67,042.

ROYAL RELATIONS

And whether the love affairs are short-lived or last a lifetime, the cachet of the famous pair-ups lives on, influencing not only prices, but the popularity of vintage styles. For centuries, styles that were fashionable in the royal courts became trends that trickled down through society. And when it came to far-reaching jewelry trends, perhaps the best example is the ring Albert gave Queen Victoria (1819-1901). The design of a coiled gold and emerald snake — combining both the symbol for eternal love and the queen’s birthstone — brought the vogue for snake jewelry to its peak, van der Vorst says. And, he adds, with the wedding of the Duke and Duchess of Cambridge, and the passing of Princess Diana’s famous sapphire and diamond engagement ring to the next generation, cluster rings have very much come back in favor. When it comes to other vintage engagement styles that are popular right now, van der Vorst says jewels from the Art Deco period are “encountering great success.”

*All prices include buyer’s premium.

Article from the Rapaport Magazine - September 2012. To subscribe click here.

Comment Comment Email Email Print Print Facebook Facebook Twitter Twitter Share Share